The Taiwan crisis is forecast as a future event. It is also a present event, conducted continuously across a spectrum of activity that does not produce headlines but does produce strategic effect. The grey zone war over Taiwan has been running for most of the last decade. Treating it as preliminary to the real war misses that the grey zone is the real war for now, and may remain so indefinitely.

The most important battle in a Taiwan conflict may be fought before the first missile is launched, on platforms that do not appear in military order-of-battle assessments, by actors who are never uniformed and never identifiable. China’s information operations against Taiwan are not a supplement to its military strategy. They are the precondition for making the military strategy work. A Taiwanese population that has been sufficiently demoralized, divided, and confused about what is actually happening and who can be trusted is a population that provides less political support for resistance, less capacity for civil defense mobilization, and less coherent pressure on allied governments to intervene.