The Center for Strategic and International Studies published a major wargame analysis of the Taiwan Strait in January 2023. It ran 24 iterations of a Chinese invasion scenario, varying assumptions about Chinese military capability, American intervention, Japanese participation, and Taiwanese defense posture. The headline finding — that the United States and its allies could likely defeat a Chinese invasion but at very high cost — made international news. The details of the analysis were more nuanced and more alarming than the headline suggested. Understanding what the wargames actually show, and what they cannot show, is prerequisite to understanding the current state of Taiwan contingency planning.